Worst Premier League Tactical Decisions

A calm day in English football is usually the one where nobody does anything daft. Yet every so often a manager reaches for a masterstroke and ends up pulling the wrong lever entirely. These tactical missteps come with numbers to back their sting, matches that still get replayed on highlight reels for all the wrong reasons, and decisions that felt baffling even as they were unfolding.

This is a look at the Premier League’s most notorious calls, shaped by context rather than hindsight, and told because some mistakes deserve more than a shrug.

José Mourinho’s High Defensive Line at Stamford Bridge, 2015

Chelsea 1 Tottenham 5 might have happened years later, but the real eyebrow-raiser was Mourinho sending a side low on confidence into a high line against Spurs at their absolute sharpest. Tottenham pressed with relentless pace and Chelsea left gaps that would have worried a non-league back four.

Key stats

• Tottenham had 57 per cent possession, unusually high for a side visiting Chelsea.

• Chelsea conceded five shots from inside the box before half time.

• Hazard completed only one successful take-on in the final third.

Memorable match
Tottenham 5 Chelsea 3. A night where Harry Kane looked as if he had been training against mannequins.

Liverpool’s All-Out Attack at Selhurst Park, 2014

Brendan Rodgers had one plan, chase goal difference. It was bold, admirable and, in truth, slightly reckless. Liverpool poured players forward after going 3-0 up and left themselves exposed in a way that neutral fans adored.

Key stats

• Liverpool had 73 per cent possession.

• Palace scored three goals in the final eleven minutes.

• Liverpool attempted 26 shots but converted only three.

Memorable match
Crystal Palace 3 Liverpool 3. The night the title charge slipped out of reach.

Louis van Gaal’s Long Ball Obsession, 2014–15

Watching Manchester United lump it forward under Van Gaal was like watching a team pretend to be something it was not. The squad had pace and technical balance but the shape forced them into rigid verticals that never suited the players.

Key stats

• United averaged only 10.7 successful dribbles per match, one of the lowest totals in the league that season.

• Their pass completion held steady at over 85 per cent, masking the lack of penetration.

• They attempted the most long passes in the top four.

Memorable match
West Ham 1 Manchester United 1. Sam Allardyce joked about a long ball approach and Van Gaal responded by printing out diagrams. A sure sign the point had been lost somewhere.

Arsène Wenger’s Open Midfield in the Big Games, 2008–14

Wenger loved expressive football. Sometimes he loved it so much that he forgot to close the gaps in midfield. Arsenal would stroll forward full of flair, only for opponents to surge through the centre like someone had left the back door open.

Key stats

• Between 2008 and 2014 Arsenal conceded four or more goals in a single Premier League match on nine occasions.

• In those games they allowed an average of 18 shots.

• They won only one of those nine fixtures.

Memorable matches
Manchester United 8 Arsenal 2. A match that will outlive every tactical lecture on compactness.

André Villas-Boas and the Ultra-High Line at Spurs, 2013

AVB’s system worked beautifully at Porto but the Premier League was less forgiving. Spurs held a wild defensive line that required split-second timing and lightning quick recovery runs, neither of which appeared very often.

Key stats

• Tottenham conceded 27 goals in their first 12 league matches that season.

• They gave up eight goals to City in one match.

• Their average defensive line height was among the top three in Europe at the time.

Memorable match
Manchester City 6 Tottenham 0. The forwards kept running into open grass and the scoreline could have been worse.

Manchester City’s Three at the Back in Monaco, 2017

Pep Guardiola likes solving problems with daring ideas. Occasionally those ideas cause more problems than they fix. Away to Monaco, City shifted to a back three that looked unsure of its roles and conceded two early goals before adjusting far too late.

Key stats

• Monaco registered eight shots on target.

• City’s xG against was 2.8, their highest in Europe that season.

• City completed only nine successful presses in the opening half hour.

Memorable match
Monaco 3 Manchester City 1. Not Premier League, but the decision affected Pep’s entire Premier League campaign and his approach to knockout matches for years after.

Frank Lampard’s Overloaded Attack, Chelsea 2019–20

Lampard trusted youthful energy over defensive structure. Chelsea looked vibrant until they ran into sides that exploited the huge pockets between midfield and defence. The attack lived on pure chaos, which is wonderful until it is not.

Key stats

• Chelsea conceded 54 league goals, their highest total in over two decades.

• They kept only one clean sheet away to a top-half side.

• Their shots for and against per match were almost identical.

Memorable match
Chelsea 2 Arsenal 2. Chelsea dominated for long stretches but kept handing Arsenal space on the break.

Ole Gunnar Solskjær’s Deep Block without a Pivot, 2019–21

Solskjær’s United often sat deep but did so without the proper holding midfielder to shield the defence. The result was a stretched shape that gave opponents room to work between the lines.

Key stats

• United conceded 44 league goals in 2020–21 despite finishing second.

• They allowed over 11 shots per match.

• Opponents completed more passes into the final third against United than any other top four club.

Memorable match
Liverpool 4 Manchester United 2. United were constantly half a step behind runners in the middle.

Rafa Benítez’s Cautious Everton, 2021

Everton fans wanted stability, but what they got was a system so cautious that it strangled its own creativity. The team sat deep, punted the ball long and left Calvert-Lewin starved of chances.

Key stats

• Everton averaged only 3.2 shots on target per match.

• Their PPDA rose to one of the highest in the league, a sign of passive pressing.

• They earned just one win in ten matches during the key winter run.

Memorable match
Everton 1 Watford 5. A tactical unravelling that summed up everything that was going wrong.

TIF Takeaway

Tactical mistakes rarely come from incompetence. They come from overconfidence, misjudged trust in player profiles, or the manager’s belief that their idea will work if they just commit to it hard enough. The Premier League thrives on boldness, which means it also thrives on the occasional spectacular miscalculation. If nothing else, these decisions live on as reminders that even elite coaches can get tangled in their own plans.

If you want, I can produce a second version with additional data tables, a ranking order, or an accompanying image brief.

Source