Best Premier League Managerial Comebacks (Ranked)
The Premier League thrives on drama, and few stories capture that better than a managerial comeback. Some returns bring trophies, others collapse under the weight of expectation, but all leave a legacy worth remembering. Here is a ranked look at the best managerial comebacks in Premier League history.
1. José Mourinho – Chelsea (2013)
When Mourinho returned to Stamford Bridge in 2013, he was tasked with restoring Chelsea to the top. Within two seasons, he delivered the Premier League title and League Cup, showing his trademark tactical discipline. The reign ended sourly, but his comeback cemented him as one of the league’s most dominant figures.
2. Harry Redknapp – Portsmouth (2005)
Redknapp’s decision to return to Portsmouth after a stint at rivals Southampton was controversial, but it became a masterstroke. He led the club to FA Cup glory in 2008, the highlight of their modern history. This comeback not only brought silverware but also gave Pompey one of their proudest moments.
3. Kenny Dalglish – Liverpool (2011)
Two decades after resigning in 1991, Dalglish returned to Liverpool to restore stability. He secured the League Cup in 2012, their first trophy in six years, and reconnected the fans with the club’s traditions. His second spell may have been short, but it gave Liverpool a much-needed sense of identity.
4. Kevin Keegan – Newcastle United (2008)
Keegan’s second stint on Tyneside came with high hopes of rekindling the attacking flair of the 1990s. Instead, disputes with the board saw him resign after just eight months. Though unsuccessful, his return highlighted how much his presence still meant to Newcastle supporters.
5. Howard Kendall – Everton (1990s)
Kendall enjoyed immense success with Everton in the 1980s, but his Premier League-era returns were less memorable. Brought back to stabilise the club, he never matched his earlier achievements, though his loyalty made his comebacks significant in their own right.
6. Alan Shearer – Newcastle United (2009)
Shearer’s interim appointment in 2009 was more symbolic than strategic. As a club legend, he was trusted to save Newcastle from relegation. Despite his passion, the team went down, but his willingness to step in at a desperate time underlined his bond with the club.
Conclusion
Managerial comebacks in the Premier League can either revive glory or end in disappointment. Mourinho and Redknapp turned their returns into trophy-winning chapters, while others like Keegan and Shearer relied more on emotional connection than results. These comebacks remind us that in football, history and sentiment often weigh as heavily as tactics and points.
